Columns And Opinions
Kenya has good laws but irredeemably tainted leaders
Members of Meru County Assembly voted to impeach Governor Kawira Mwangaza. The MCAs advanced numerous impeachment grounds, including nepotism and abuse of office. The governor, who this week went before a Senate committee, argues that the impeachment was political vendetta fuelled by the fact that she is politically “independent”. The Senate overturned her impeachment.
If the impeachment articles as advanced by the MCAs were partly or wholly true, then the governor has no business running a kindergarten, let alone a county government. However, if her impeachment was arising from disagreements on policy positions, or, as she claims, political vendetta, then the country as a whole must find a constitutional or statutory way of, (1) taming “ trigger-happy” MCAs; and (2) removing the obvious conflict of interest arising from senators presiding over cases of governors they have ambitions of replacing.
If we look at past impeachment cases, we notice that the process is open to abuse and political manipulation. For instance, one governor was impeached and removed from office for grand thievery while the impeachment of another, who was charged with murder, failed, and he went on to serve out his term.
A past report by the auditor-general indicated that almost all governors had serious audit queries, yet only a few of them faced impeachment. In the case of Makueni County, MCAs attempted to remove then-Governor Kivutha Kibwana because he refused to accommodate their unethical or even illegal monetary demands.
In other instances, governors avoided impeachment by succumbing to blackmail from MCAs. These discrepancies and mafia-style tactics indicate the need to standardise the threshold for impeachment so that the process is above political vendetta, whimsicality, frivolity and criminality.
Then there are conflict of interest issues. Can a senator or MCA who wants to succeed a governor be objective in a case involving the person he/she wants to replace? Similarly, can a senator or MCA who belongs to a party different from that of the governor be an impartial arbiter in a case involving the governor?
Also, some senators have integrity issues which, in more serious jurisdictions, would prove crippling to their political careers. For instance, in the last Senate, someone who was accused of buying wheelbarrows for tens of thousands of shillings apiece and ball pens for hundreds of shillings per pen when he was governor presided over the Senate, which supposedly oversights county expenditure! Other senators have been involved in malpractices or alleged thievery in their previous careers as lawyers or government officials. Can they oversight the spending of public funds in counties?
All this brings us back to a fundamental dilemma. We have institutions and constitutional infrastructure, but we have irredeemably morally compromised officials. The façade of constitutionalism gives us the illusion of progress, but we are in fact stagnated.
Tee Ngugi is a Nairobi-based political commentator.
Cabinet Approves Extradition Deal Between Kenya and China
Marburg Virus Outbreak Kills Five People In Tanzania » Uzalendo News
President Ruto Responds To Raila’s Weekly Protests
Shock as kenyan diaspora man edward morema and wife murdered
Twenty-Three Kenyan Entrepreneurs to represent the country in the upcoming Forty Under 40 Africa Awards 2023 : TechMoran
Latest Mobile App Development Trends To Dominate In 2023 : TechMoran
Chevrolet Camaro will be dead officially after 2024 : TechMoran
Marburg virus related to Ebola hits Tanzania, kills five people
Foreign Investors Assume Net Buying After A Series Of Selling
The Standard – Breaking News, Kenya News, World News and Videos
‘I’m dying sis,’ Kunguru’s last words to the sister, Irene Onguru – Kenya Satellite News Network
Lawyer Miguna Miguna retracts tweet accusing Raila Odinga of altering image of police brutality
10 Key Conversations Shaping The Future
Photos: Jeff Mwathi’s body reburied after dramatic exhumation exercise
Raila Defends Cherera 4 Actions In Attack On US Ambassador
The Benefits of Cryptocurrency Betting on Golf with Sportsbet.io
Interior CS Kithure Kindiki named among 50 African trailblazers
Oldest Golf tournament Tannahill Shield confirmed for Easter Weekend – Capital Sports – Nairobi Times
Inflation holds steady at 9.2 percent in March
Maxine Wahome leaves prison after paying bond
General News6 days ago
Tornadoes Kill 23 And Bring Devastation To Mississippi – Eagle News Feed – Nairobi Times
General News1 day ago
At Least Eight Dead In India Temple Collapse » Uzalendo News
Entertainment5 days ago
Azimio must train supporters on peaceful demos
General News6 days ago
Menengai heal from Kenya Cup heartache with thrashing of Zetech Oaks in Mwamba Cup opener – Capital Sports – Nairobi Times
Politics6 days ago
KURA boss Kinoti joins President Ruto Nyanza Projects tour – Weekly Citizen
General News4 days ago
Waiyaki Way, Other Nairobi Roads Barricaded by Police During Raila Protests [FULL LIST]
Tech5 days ago
Paying for a blue badge on Twitter, are you game?
Sports3 days ago
Uganda edge Tanzania to revive 2023 Afcon hopes