Dear Baraza,
I am gearing up to buy my first car but I am unable to decide whether to buy a VW Golf MK6, Mazda Axela, Subaru Impreza or Toyota Fielder. I have a young family and enjoy driving. Road trips will definitely be a family affair once I get a car. Kindly advice on maintenance costs, spare part costs and availability and overall ride experience amongst these brands. Also comment on the gear box and engine trouble with the VW Golf.
Evans
Hello Evans,
Let's get down to it, shall we?
You enjoy driving? The Golf 6 and the Axela would like to have your contacts. The Impreza would like your attention too, but don't mind it much if it has no turbo. However, when it comes to road trips, the Fielder with its superior size wins overall, followed by the rest in order of driving sensation.
If you choose to "upgrade" the Golf to Variant spec, it swings back into the lead.
Maintenance costs: this is a two-way battle between the cliché and the yob-star: Fielder versus Impreza. The Fielder is a contender because it is relatively simple and parts are common. Just try and overlook the fact that a lot of these parts may be from stolen vehicles hence their ubiquity.
The Impreza is a contender because Subarus are very hardy vehicles as long as you maintain oil levels at the recommended state at all times.
By the time the oil pressure warning comes on in a Subaru, it's too late; that engine is gone.
This doesn't mean the Golf and the Axela are expensive to maintain, no, they're still cheap to own and run especially with meticulous preventative maintenance, it's just that this pair is a little more sensitive to mistreatment and once victimised, you now have to look for spare parts...
Spare part costs and availability: Somebody online alleged that no car has cheap parts, which is true - if you fall within a certain tax bracket then everything is expensive. Take, for example, El Turbo.
One headlamp costs Sh17,000 on the black market, which is horribly expensive. But then again one headlamp from a Land Rover Freelander 2 costs Sh130,000, which makes my BH5 Revision D candles look cheap by comparison.
So, take it to mean what it means but the Subaru and the Toyota stand on one side of the fence grinning while the Volkswagen and the Mazda stand on the other screaming "WE WANT A REMATCH": The People's Car being on the grounds that it's German while the Hiroshima Hauler suffering from allegations of scarcity and "sparsity" of sundry spares.
Overall ride experience: The Golf is the best, by a country mile. It's a small German that feels like a big German inside, which is high praise as far as ride quality goes. The Fielder is the worst. You can tell it is mass-produced by a company focused on assembly line efficiency, not proving a point. The Axela is second and the Impreza third.
Gearbox issues in the Golf were more or less sorted out with the Mk. V generation. It involved a supplier dabbling in low quality materials for transmission fasteners which would lead the gearbox to huff and puff and blow itself in with use, but that has since been resolved.
As for engine issues... if you get a turbo Golf then somewhere along the line that turbo will start sucking in oil and blowing it out the tailpipe in the form of thick white smoke, so start doing your math right now (it's not as tragic as it sounds; also though the probability is high, it's not a guarantee it will happen).
As for the legendary Check Engine Light, it usually stems from many things, some as serious as the deflowered turbocharger, some as trivial as a loose fuel filler cap (yes, a loose fuel cap can also throw a CEL. Cars can be funny sometimes). Don't let it scare you until you confirm the worst with an OBD II scan.
What can you tell me about the Mazda CX-5 diesel?
Dear Baraza,
I find your column informative and I like the independent mindedness in embracing some models less popular with Kenyans. I currently drive the Axela and before it, the Demio.
I want to stick to the Mazda make. Please compare the CX-5 diesel and petrol since my mechanic advised against diesel. I like the AWD however. I also admire the RX8 horsepower and would like it later. Tell me about the rotary engine.
Kahariri
Kahariri,
I also advised against the CX-5 diesel some time back. The essence of that disquisition was the diesel engine in the CX-5 is failure-prone to the point of instigating recalls and TSBs, so you may want to steer clear of it.
As for the rotary engine, there are very good reasons why nobody does them. Mazda insisted through the ‘90s with the RX-7 then sobered up and dropped it.
Then they said “Naah, there is something we were overlooking” and tried it yet again with the short-lived RX-8 and rediscovered what made rotaries fancy but inappropriate in the first place: the engine eats the oil seals at the rotor tips like you won’t believe.
Oil consumption is high. Fuel consumption is horrendous. These engines are powerful for what they are but the power lies somewhere past the stratosphere, so you have to work really hard to tap into it.
The sky-high peak power levels are occasioned by the biggest failing of them all, given that it’s a sports car, there is no torque at all, so what you end up with is a car with Saturn V looks but to get it off the ground you have to rev and rev and rev and keep the revs boiling until you get sick of it and start Googling “RX-8 engine swaps”.
I drove one with the late Paji (RIP) and it was just... tiresome. You can’t even get the back to slide out (this is why RWD sports cars exist: to get them to shake what their “mama”-nufacturers gave them) unless you are well north of 6500rpm which means you are always mindful of what gear you are in and what rev range you are playing with; which in turn means there is barely time to concentrate on steering and counter-steering, which in turn means you either over-rev the engine or crash the vehicle or both, if you are nothing special behind the wheel.
Of course there is a consequence to the masticated rotor tips, oil guzzling and redline shenanigans: shortened engine life, and I do mean severely shortened: we are talking engine failures and replacements at mileages as low as 150,000km only, more so for those who have low seat time and subpar maintenance protocols.
It’s not all doom and gloom though. The engine may be a weak point but the rest of the car isn’t. The looks: stunning, even now, many years after it fell off the shelf. The handling is superb: it is one of the best driving cars.
I have been in, and that is counting for something given that I have driven hundreds of cars from all kinds of segments including Nissan GTRs and Jaguar F Types and Mercedes AMGs and whatnot. I’d get one if I could and worry about that engine later.
Which locally used car would a budget of Sh300,000 - Sh450,000 get me?
Hey Baraza,
I would love to buy a locally used car. My budget is between Sh300,000 - Sh450,000. A friend suggests that I go for a Toyota but I want a Subaru, Nissan or Mitsubishi. My questions:
a) is it possible to get a good car within the price range?
b) how do Mitsubishi, Nissan and Toyota compare on fuel and reliability.
Kidds
Hi Kidds!
Would you like some brand sense?
Wanna see me stick my neck out and lay bare some controversial tidbits?
Wanna copy me and do exactly like I did?
Bought a Subaru in that price range; see now where my life is!
My advice carries weight;
So best to get your head straight
As I help you figure out whether a Mitsubishi is what you want to operate.
Toyotas will always live;
Mitsubishis are ready to die;
Nissans will have to be carried inside
A cemetery and buried alive
a) Yes, it is possible to get a fairly good car at that price range, but hedge your bets by focusing more on the 450 side than on the 300.
For Toyotas, we are looking at G Touring, Corolla 110s and Corona Premios. You could get a Probox too.
For Mitsubishis, try a Lancer, though at 450, even a Pajero V46 is within reach at a pinch if you want to go down that path.
Nissan? Wingroads abound. I’m not going to add B15s to the list because those things belong in the skip, but you could shop around for early Sylphys, they’re not half bad.
The Subaru lineup is quintessential: Impreza (first gen), Forester (first gen), Legacy (third gen).
Essentially, at that price range you are looking at saloons and wagons from around the turn of the millennium or earlier if you want something in good nick. Newer vehicles within that range are likely to be in poorer shape.
b) Fuel consumption is just about even across the board when you compare like for like, but the Pajero iO - the little ‘un - has been known to be unreasonably thirsty.
Reliability? Go through my bastardised version of Eminem’s debut hit single up there for reference. There are some not-so-subtle hints within the lyrics
Mwalimu, buy the Toyota Fielder, but you might not own it for long…
Hi,
I desperately need your help. I’m planning to buy my first car after this corona. I am a teacher in Homabay. I need a car that doesn’t consume a lot of fuel, at least 13km/l litre, easy to maintain, a durable and strong car that can go off-road once in a while. I don’t know which one to buy between a fielder 1500cc (2wd/1800(2wd/1500(4wd and 1800(4wd). I will greatly appreciate your help. My budget is Sh800,000.
Hello, Mwalimu,
I am not sure “after corona” will be any time soon or if there will even be an “after corona” at all, but this is not the place to discuss global pandemics.
The Fielder you pine after will do 13km/l, is easy to maintain and is durable (relatively) but where you fall off the wagon (pun intended) is the off-road part.
This is how to kill a car quickly: use it for purposes outside that car’s skill set. I’d advise you look a little further up the motor vehicle hierarchy for this: perhaps an older RAV4 or first generation X-Trail would do nicely. Or a Subaru Forester.
However, now that you really want a Fielder, I doubt I will dissuade you, so, of the lot you list, go for the 1800.
It will still do 13km/l no matter what naysayers may say, just brush up on your self-control, particularly in your right foot.
One more thing: I don’t know what the security situation in Homa Bay is like, but over here in the locked down county number 047, it has become something of a running joke comparing buying a Fielder to growing maize by the roadside (or marrying into unbridled beauty).
You will receive unwanted assistance in possessing that which is rightfully yours. Your stuff will be stolen, in short, more a matter of when than if. The Fielder has become a hotcake among the TWOCcing* set.
[*TWOC: /t-wo:k/
(verb) Taking Without Owner’s Consent]



