It seems unbelievable that caning in schools is back on the table as a topic for Kenyans to debate, but now that it is, it is important to understand where the issues with regard to student discipline begin.
Many Kenyans now aged above 18 were brought up in homes, and very likely went to schools where corporal punishment was used to discipline children, minors and students who had done wrong.
Corporal punishment was usually dispensed in a gendered manner, where teachers, unfortunately, exercised more freedom while dispensing it on boys and on girls who had personalities more associated with masculinity.
This followed the colonial stereotype that African children in general, and specifically stronger-bodied students, could take more pain. Many girls still did not escape beatings both at home and at school. The punishing stakeholder would use hands or even feet to dispense blows and kicks in order to cause pain. Others used things like wooden rulers, iron rods and sticks, or even the rubber whips commonly carried by guards as weapons.
Another method involved causing discomfort within the minor’s body. This could be achieved by making the minor kneel down with hands up, so that loss of blood flow to their arms, and the effort involved in keeping the hands up, would cause pain.
Other common punishments involved being left outside alone on scary nights, in intense cold or other unpleasant weather conditions, or allocation of massive portions of undesirable chores with poor tools, to augment their difficulty.
Sign up for free AllAfrica Newsletters
Get the latest in African news delivered straight to your inbox
Success!
Almost finished…
We need to confirm your email address.
To complete the process, please follow the instructions in the email we just sent you.
Error!
There was a problem processing your submission. Please try again later.
Fear and shame
On punishment of young people, the first question that should be asked is whether pain is the only way of passing the intended message. In whose best interest is the pain experienced? Are there other ways of communicating displeasure and denying privileges?
Evidence says that young people associate physical punishment with fear and shame, more than care or correction. Further sociological exposition reflects that the show of power in physical beatings works to prevent young people from feeling safe around authority figures.
It also makes them vulnerable to abusive situations by normalising physical violence against anyone who is seen to be vulnerable.
It is likely that people cane students because they do not know what else to do as punishment. Despite their own history, it does not mean there is no better way. Instead of encouraging violence as a problem-solving mechanism when evidence has long shown that it is not, state, educational, psychological and other stakeholders should work to honour Kenyan constitutional statements about children’s rights.
Research and dedicated public conversation, including with the minors themselves, can be used to come up with constructive punishment mechanisms so that young people still trust those in authority. If as adults we are punished by law for using violence to solve disputes, we should stop using these methods on children, so that they can have a chance at a better and more caring future.
The writer is a policy analyst. [email protected]